After being forced to cut their recent New York show at Central Park’s SummerStage short due to inclement weather, Guster have made good on their promise to return to the city for a “new and improved, weather resistant” make-up performance.

The gig will take place Nov. 30 at NYC’s Terminal 5 and will be a rare two-set affair for the group, including one set that will consist of fan-selected songs. Those going to the show can vote for their favorite Guster tunes (or songs they’d like the group to cover) here.

Tickets from the truncated Aug. 8 SummerStage show will be honored at the new date, and a limited number of new tickets are on sale now. Those unable to attend the rescheduled date can seek refunds at point of purchase.