Deer Tick and Delta Spirit closed out their Friend Ship tour at New York’s Webster Hall on Tuesday night. During the night’s encore, the two groups joined together for a series of songs, as they often have this run: Cheap Trick’s “Surrender,” the self-titled song by Middle Brother, Deer Tick’s “Ashamed” and the traditional “La Bamba,” which Deer Tick were inspired to cover after hearing Los Lobos’ take on the selection. In addition, during Deer Tick’s set, Delta Spirit’s Matt Vasquez sat in on Middle Brother’s “Daydreaming.” (Middle Brother is an indie-folk supergroup featuring Vasquez, Deer Tick’s John J. McCauley and Dawes’ Taylor Goldsmith.)

A few other guest appearances dotted Deer Tick’s recent setlists. During both their Monday and Tuesday stops at Webster Hall, Robert Ellis played keyboards throughout Deer Tick’s entire show. On Monday, The Tallest Man on Earth also emerged for a cover of Bob Dylan’s “Tonight I’ll Be Staying Here With You,” a fitting selection since the show took place during the Bard’s recent New York run.