Skip to Content
Features

Mike Gordon’s Tiny Little World

12:00 AM EST on February 7, 2014

Photo by Rene Huemer

Mike Gordon has always loved lists. From archiving his favorite jams to choosing the names of potential Phish festivals, the bassist has consistently been hyper-organized when it comes to documenting his creative process. So it is no surprise that each of Gordon’s solo albums has honed in on a very specific style and technique. His latest effort Overstep centers on Gordon’s longtime working relationship with Max Creek guitarist Scott Scott Murawski. The album is the culmination of, in Gordon’s words, an over three-decade “bromance.”

Max Creek were one of the first bands to expose Gordon to the New England jamband scene and Murawski had a profound influence on the young musician’s style and technique. (Gordon famously tricked Phish into playing Max Creek’s “Back Porch Boogie Blues” in the 1980s by telling the rest of the band it was his song.) After a series of sit-ins and jam sessions in the ‘90s and early ‘00s, Gordon brought Murawski on the road in 2003 in support of Inside In, the companion piece to the film Outside Out. Murawski was Gordon’s first call when he put together a solo band in 2008 and has remained a steady member of his group ever since.

For Overstep, Gordon and Murawski spent several years co-writing a new batch of songs and then, laid those tracks down with the help of former Pearl Jam drummer Matthew Chamberlain and noted alt-rock producer Paul Q. Kolderie. A true collaborative effort, all of the songs on Overstep were co-written, and Murawski actually sings lead vocals on a few tunes. Gordon finished work on Overstep in 2013, shortly before Phish returned to the studio in Nashville, TN with producer Bob Erzin to work on the songs they debuted on Halloween as part of Wingsuit (two of those songs stemmed from the same songwriting sessions as Overstep ). Below, Gordon walks us through his creative process and his recent studio sessions.

Each of your solo albums have centered around a very specific and very different creative process. Overstep, in particular, seems based around your writing and working relationship with Max Creek guitarist Scott Murawski, who is also a longtime member of your solo band. Did you originally set out to write a full album of songs with Scott?

It kind of started with the feeling of just enjoying Scott’s company. I had this little epiphany when I was having one of my artist’s dates for The Artist’s Way [art collective] in St. Albans, Vermont where I never go otherwise. It’s an interesting town pretty far from here—about 45 minutes outside Burlington, Vt. It’s just a little bit north of us, and it’s an old military base with statues and this large green space. I was walking around there, and I just pictured Scott and I somewhere in New England in some little, empty cabin with no fridge and just a desk and some guitars. It would be very spare in the middle of nowhere, and we can just concentrate on jamming and coming up with just fun things.

Some people have such a hard time with songwriting, and I’ve certainly gone through dry phases like anyone else. There’s a Jerry Garcia quote where he says he’d rather be reading the VCR manual or feeding the cat than working on a song. And I’ve felt that before but this ended up being the exact opposite. I had this feeling like, “I don’t even care what we end up with, I just like hanging out with this guy,” as bromance-y as it sounds. It was more about imagining us hunkering down with no pressure and just having fun and seeing what happens. And the vision was multipart, too. I think I was imagining having a stage filled with mirrors for our band to play in front of [Laughter.] So that was kind of the vision and then, we started having these writing sessions. They were really fun but they were also hard. But whenever I was driving to work with Scott I had this feeling like I’m the king of the world because I’m doing something I want to do.

I remember the first time I drove down to Sunapee, New Hampshire to meet Scott. It was snowing and for the first time in a long time I didn’t listen to any music, and I didn’t make any phone calls on my drive. I usually listen to my hotline messages but this time I did nothing. I just drove down and kept thinking—it was like a meditation and I was just so excited. It was like taking a jet pack down to Sunapee, which eventually was going to be the album title, Jet Pack.

Do you think you will end up incorporating mirrors in your live show?

That was originally going to be part of the idea when we took it to the road. There would be mirrors everywhere. We have great stuff [for the live show] but I don’t think we have mirrors.

How close to your original vision did your songwriting sessions end up being?

When we first got there we didn’t know what the hell to do. We didn’t know how to put our ideas together, and every time I felt the same thing happening. We would get together, and it would seem so fun and then, we would be there and we would be going a little crazy figuring out how to get our ideas organized. Then, when I left and I had this feeling like we hadn’t done too much and when we drove away and listened to the demos we made, and I realized we had done just as much as we set out to do. It’s just a funny cycle like that. I would actually say it was kind of an epiphany that I need to get together and write with this guy mainly because it would be fun.

You ended up writing more songs than can fit on a single album but at what point in the writing process over the past few years did you feel like you had enough material for a unified album?

We took our time because we didn’t want to rush it and there were different phases. Sometimes we weren’t working so much and other times when I was off from Phish tour we were working every afternoon. At a certain point we realized we had eight good songs, and we went in one five day stretch to North Adams, Massachusetts and came up with eight more which we hadn’t expected. And of those eight more I only thought there were three good ones but they all ended up being great and pretty much are all on the album. Not all of them but most of them. There’s some extra tracks too that we haven’t decided what to do with.

Eventually you brought in Paul Q. Kolderie, who has worked with Radiohead, Uncle Tupelo, Pixies and Portugal. The Man, but was something of a wild-card choice for you. How did you land on him as your producer and what were his initial impressions of all these songs you had stockpiled with Scott?

We went through some interesting phases. The first phase was that someone recommended we work with David Fridmann, who does all The Flaming Lips records. It’s a very distinctive, peculiar, interesting lo-fi recording style and it was really tweaking my brain. I was driving around listening to everything David Fridmann had done because, in some ways, he was the perfect guy and, in other ways, he was not the perfect guy, and I had no idea whether he would work with us or even had time. But it just didn’t fit. The ideas didn’t fit regardless of whether he would have done it. Then we met a couple producers, and we talked through some long lists of questions. I tend to generate long lists of ideas and there were a lot of people that didn’t quite fit but that were great. I thought about Joe Henry who did Bonnie Raitt’s last album and a lot of other albums. He’s great, and he’s a songwriter but maybe kind of not quirky enough. He might not have understood the humor in it as much. It just might not have been the perfect fit.

Then there were two guys we met and both were great, but with Paul it just kind of felt like he was into what we already had done in terms of some of the things that were making it a little unpredictable sounding. He’s a real philosophical guy and we just kind of sat around and had these long conversations and it just felt good. He also does everything himself: he engineers, produces, assists, fixes your guitar amp and etcetera. And he had lived only a few miles from New England so that kind of felt like this was a whole New England conceived project. I really liked that he was able to dart through the hills and meet us here and meet us there. That just felt right, too. I like the idea of making something that is ‘of the region,’ the hills of New England. Even meeting Scott [years ago], I would sort of drive around and see Max Creek in some old barn in the middle of Western Massachusetts. Our whole friendship has been sort of New England based so to get Paul, who is from the same turf, felt sort of right too.

You wrote most of the songs on your previous solo albums yourself but you also have a long history of songwriting collaborations, including two albums with Leo Kottke. I heard you even toyed with the idea of releasing Overstep under both your and Scott’s name. How did this project relate to your previous songwriting collaborations?

Well, each collaboration is different. You can look at the Rolling Stones as an example. Mick Jagger is known to be the guy who is always planning, and making lists and organizing and Keith Richards is kind of the guy who goes with the flow a lot. They sometimes clash over that. I feel a little bit like that with Scott. I’m just always over planning and he’s very disciplined but when he can he prefers to go with the flow. So we kind of make a good mix in that way. And I find that every album that I make tends to be in some way a reaction to the previous one. That’s even the case with Phish.

How would you say Overstep is a reaction to Moss ?

I love [2010’s] Moss. There’s something kind of dreamy about it for me. Moss is also sort of stepping in the direction of being a little bit about the song for me, paring down for me as compared with Green Sparrow. So in that sense it wasn’t only a reaction to the previous album but a continuation of simplifying the songs. They could breathe a little more and go in with less of an arrangement. But I think some of it doesn’t stem from the previous album but stems from the live show.

That’s the great thing about being in a band with Scott and then writing with him. We had written a little bit before. There’s this song “Short Circuit” that we wrote which ended up on my benefit album Steamroller Wheelies: A Restoration Convoy. The cool thing is that since we stand on stage together we know what we like to play and there are a lot of different kinds of moods, grooves and emotions that we tend to dabble in just because of the way our personalities are. So it’s really easy to ask ourselves, “Well, what do we want to be standing up on stage and have in the repertoire?” [Laughter.] And for me, I definitely wanted some stuff that’s kind of danceable. Actually, that’s one of my taboo words in talking about the album. But maybe it’s not even the richest word either.

But I wanted to be able to stand up there and be able to sing together with a lot of harmonies and have some really simple, really strong grooves that we can just sink our teeth into. Each of my albums also has sort of a different main instrument. On Green Sparrow, it was the guitar and on Moss it was pedal steel or the bass. A lot of the songs on Moss have interesting bass lines and that’s what they revolve around. But the problem with having bass lines that are so syncopated and intricate is that it is hard to then sing at the same time.

Now, I’ve just been really concentrating on singing, and I just always find that I enjoy having very simple bass lines to sing with. It doesn’t make the bass worse. I think it makes everything better. I think that one of the goals was to have music where the grooves are kind of simpler so we could kind of just rock them out but where it’s not dumb music either—where the arrangements have some sophistication even more than before. So maybe some of the bridge chords are us pushing our limits of moving around the chords and the harmonies and certain beats dropped where it just kind of flows, and it is allowed to be sophisticated but within the context of being much simpler. So that was one of the goals besides just writing and seeing that happens.

Given that you were designing these songs to go hand in hand with the live show, was there a reason you decided to hold off from playing these songs live with your solo band over the last two years besides the two ones you played with Phish this summer [“Yarmouth Road” and “Say Something”]?

Well, at first I had trouble deciding if I should bring any songs to Phish when they weren’t close to being released or done. But I’m glad I did because we had fun with them. The main reason is that I’ve just been busy working on all sorts of projects. I wish I could do things more simultaneously—like being on the road and writing songs, which I’ve done a little bit of recently or working on multiple things. I am a multi-tasker but it just ends up being better if I focus—I can spread myself thin. So by not wanting to play for awhile we were able to concentrate on building up some new material and just focusing on the songwriting. I think that’s kind of the reason for that.

But it is weird not to have played most of these songs before the album comes out. I mean, one definitely could make an argument for playing stuff before recording it, which of course Phish just did. But I like to craft albums like a painting, and I kind of like people to hear the album version first, if possible, and then let the stage version be completely different. I think maybe sometime we will do it the other way around. But I like saying, “Okay, well this is the version that can be crafted in the studio and now let’s see how we can take that and change it radically or let it evolve for the stage.” And that’s fun for me to kind of explore both. If it is the other way around, I kind of worry about it becoming too much arranged for the stage and then maybe I worry it would be kind of harder to do the studio version because I just enjoy them being different kinds of animals.

Speaking of the Wingsuit seasons, two of the songs Phish debuted on Halloween, “Snow” and “555,” were collaborations with Scott. Did those stem form the same writing sessions as the Overstep songs?

Yeah. That’s a good question. “Snow” was one of the 16 songs that we ended up with after our writing sessions. We weren’t trying to have 16 [songs on Overstep ], and I knew that not all of them would…we loved all of them but not all of them would fit together as an overall piece. We just always loved “Snow,” but we just thought that [it didn’t quite fit on the album]. The goal wasn’t about being as eclectic as possible especially when my favorite albums are ones that kind of keep a vibe going—not 100% because if every song is the same then maybe it’s boring—but within being in the same ballpark of a mood. I kind of like to listen to whole albums like that. So “Snow” is just an example of a song that didn’t quite fit the mood.

It is always so nice to hear the demos before we recorded with Paul. “Snow” was one of the first eight actually but then it just didn’t seem to fit the overall mood. So it was just one of those ones we didn’t know what we would do with but Phish just seemed to gravitate toward it and [ Wingsuit producer] Bob Ezrin did immediately. He went through…we had our many choices down to 25 songs and Ezrin told us which ones shouldn’t be and should be on the album and which were maybes out of all 25 songs. “Snow” was the first one that he thought should definitely go on the album, which I was surprised about. It’s got its own vibe but that’s been really nice and he took what he did and did more with it.

[For “555,”] when Scott and I went back to a different part of New Hampshire that is near Concord, New Hampshire we wrote some new songs and one of them became “555.” It stemmed from the same session in New Hampshire where my band had just jammed and come up with some material. There’s great stuff but we really haven’t had time to mine it.

Do you feel that in the last few years, as you’ve gotten older and made more and more albums, you have gravitated more toward this idea of the thematically-linked album rather than the idea of a collection of songs that happened to be recorded around the same time, with the same band or producer?

Yeah, I think so. I like things that fit together so I think it happens anyway subconsciously because if you take a certain method, a certain process, or a certain person to collaborate with over a certain time period then you end up with a distinctive body of work to some extent anyway. We will talk through our lyrical ideas or our music ideas but with the music sometimes Scott and I will just like we’ll have an idea that is an inking of an idea and we’ll just kind of close our eyes and imagine ourselves on stage—maybe not the typical gig maybe it’s like some weird gig in Bali or something.

We talk about what it feels like and what the song needs. So we’re kind of asking our subconscious, or our group subconscious—our paired subconscious—and then lyrically there’s going to be stuff in a given time period that we’re just kind of thinking about as individuals. Some songs are just about things we’re excited about and some songs were about reflecting or being contemplative about some moment or person in our lives. We would end talking through these moments like therapy a lot of the time just to make sure the lyrics are resonating on some level that’s meaningful. I think some of that happens on auto pilot. Maybe as we get older we get better at choosing what’s cohesive for an album and keeping it within a theme even if it’s not a concept album, per say, although that can be fun, too.

Were there any specific lyrical themes that you kind of felt kept coming up during your recent songwriting sessions?

There are these themes having to do with alienation or a delusion—imagining yourself in a situation or relationship that doesn’t necessarily exist or exist in the way that you think it does. For example, in “Yarmouth Road” he’s building this house with someone and then realizes he forgot to check with the person to see whether or not they want to be building it or moving into it and anything you do and you think the other person is on board and they’re not. Or “Tiny Little World” he’s just kind of watching someone in the coffee shop and imagining the next step and then they’re at this dance club and then they’re forming a life together and then oops he has another life and he’s leading a double life and then it all goes sour and then it’s like oh no forget it just let it be a fantasy. It’s kind of like being displaced, being one-stepped removed from these relationships. I think that’s kind of the theme.

Maybe that’s a little fuzzy and a little vague. Even though I’m not allowed to talk about it, probably the idea of dancing and bopping around is a theme partly just because I was inspired by these grooves I would take to our songwriting sessions. Not all the time but some of the times, I hear something on the radio and I didn’t like the song at all but wanted to take some groove and work with it because it just felt good. If we’re at soundcheck and we start playing or even just at a gig and make up a jam there’s going to be some grooves that just feel good for the band and those are things in a way that should be songs because they just feel good. So I thought, “Well, a groove itself is not a song and it’s probably the furthest thing from a song. A melody is closer and a lyric or phrase are definitely closer, but still a groove is a feeling with its spaciousness and its propulsion and everything that a groove has and energy and sweat and that should feel good.” So it was this idea of feeling good and if we feel good hanging out and writing together then we might as well also feel good with a kind of tempo and groove and syncopation that we’re using as the pulse. So that’s kind of like an indirect theme I guess.

When you hear something at a show or soundcheck that you think would be an interesting part of a song, do you still immediately write it in your journal after the show?

Well, I’m such an organization freak that I tend to keep playlists of ideas. If I think of some guitar lick that I think should be worked into a song, I record it onto my iPhone and then when I’m going through my voicemail I email it to myself. I download it to the desktop but then I bring it in to a folder I call riffs for songs. When Scott and I get together it’s a lot more human than that so it’s pretty rare that we are using those actual files.

I remember the first time I played him the whole folder which is called Riffs for Songs. And that’s only one thing because I have an equivalent place for lyrical ideas and then, I’ve got another place for some of these grooves I’m inspired by and then, I’ve got another place for some of the jam sessions we’ve had. [As I said before], my band went to New Hampshire a couple of years and for three days we just jammed.

I read that Bob Dylan does the same thing and most people just kind of keep a stockpile of musical and lyrical ideas and then they kind of revisit them the notebooks or whatever. But when Scott and I are together almost all of that is almost negligible—it’s just a tiny inkling to kind of get our ideas flowing and then when Scott and I were in North Adams we were using artwork and all these paintings around the town and those were just as, my riffs for songs and those paintings… it almost doesn’t matter where the idea starts from, it matters where it goes and whether we can sort of nurture it a place because we’re feeling it based on the feeling. Otherwise it’s just like firewood for the fire.

Given that these songs were created in such a songwriting environment, how’s it I guess, what’s the process been like so far to kind of bring these songs to life on the stage?

Well, we’ve been having rehearsals since last October on and off. I think it’s really just a matter of matching the situation or letting the situation dictate what it wants. In the case of my band you know when it really happened is the last rehearsal. It was really intense. It was a week-long rehearsal and we were in three different locations and we were trying some new technology for the stage and then we went to a log home. We borrowed or rented a log home and we went in with practically no gear—just small stuff by a fireplace in the living room, looking up and there was like views out the back door, back windows And so by paring it down, almost back to the same exact vibe that we were in when we were writing the songs and we were working on our old repertoire and rearranging some stuff and some new cover songs too.

It wasn’t all the album material but it was focused on the album. What was really just an awesome feeling was that the band started to sound like itself more than ever before just its own combination of attributes. [Percussionist] Craig Myers might have been playing his N’goni. It is not that we’re the only band that has a N’goni because Toubab Krewe uses one but we’re the only band with this pile of attributes and a couple new instruments that I have and then a couple new ideas that we’ve had for jamming.

We were in a room together without much stuff sort of boiling down with the fireplace and everything—it just felt it was playing itself. And so I thought the most important thing would be to have some great new songs to play and we’ve worked on that. Then the other thing is to say, “Well, it doesn’t matter what song we’re playing we just want to allow ourselves to sound like ourselves like I was saying in terms of playing a groove we would naturally play at a soundcheck or in between songs because it just happens to feel good or not playing but making it up maybe.”

It’s the same kind of thing with letting people play, just fall into their instruments whatever they are and doing the kinds of stuff on them. I mean I’m speaking the obvious but it was really kind of enlightening to be in that room and just realize, “Oh we’ve really let ourselves sound like ourselves.” You know, we’ve tried to cultivate that where of course we’re going to sound somewhat like Phish or any of the other bands that the band members came from or any influences that we’ve had. But trying to say, “Well okay we know where we all come from, we’re not always going to follow that path, we’re just going to see what this sounds like.”

I was just really excited that was happening. I love the live Egg release that we did and just feeling like, “Wow, in only a few years we got this band to really kind of have a chemistry” because I like the way that release sounds and then to add a new repertoire, I’ve kind of felt like, well this is just great. We’re kind of trying to put it all together and just having an incredible time is the goal.