During a recent appearance on The Howard Stern Show, Dave Matthews busted out an acoustic version of Procol Harum’s late-‘60s classic “A Whiter Shade of Pale.”

And while it was performed as recently as June 2018 in a duo format with Tim Reynolds, this marks Matthews’ first solo version of the song since October 2015.

“Beautiful,” Stern remarks following the performance. “I’m going to give you a 10 [out of 10].”

Watch below: